Buyers Guide to Operating Systems
from Acu IT Solutions
Few people realise they have a choice when it comes
to operating systems. For a long time there has not been a choice
for the home user. Old timers hark back to the days when you could
opt for DR-Dos in preference to Microsoft's MS-Dos, but the software
giant killed off that choice with Windows.
Now things have changed somewhat, mainly thanks to Linus (pronounced
Linn-us) Torvalds who created Linux. The Linux phenomenon has grown
exponentially in the intervening years and, since round 1998 when
the big computer manufacturers started taking it seriously, has
become very popular. The biggest difference between Microsoft Windows
and Linux is the licensing model that each uses.
LICENCES
Every software package comes with a licence, and
operating systems are no different. Most PCs come bundled with Microsoft
Windows and even though you buy the whole system from the hardware
vendor, a portion of the cost goes back to Microsoft for the Windows
licence.
This licence does not mean that you own the operating system. All
it does is give you the right to use it as specified in the licence.
Many people are surprised to discover that the Windows licence does
not give them the right to install the operating system on another
PC - even if they wipe it off the PC it originally came with.
The Linux operating system is based on the GNU Public Licence,
which has many peculiar features. The GNU Public licence says that
you not only have the right to install and run the software on as
many PCs as you want and even make copies to pass on to other people
(so long as you include a copy of the GNU licence), but it also
means you have access to the source code.
For many people, access to the source code is academic: you cannot
do anything with it unless you understand programming languages.
You can compile it to run on your machine, but the boxed product
is already compiled anyway and ready to run. But theoretical access
to the source code is important because this is how programmers
all over the world are able to help debug, tweak and improve the
code.
Further reading on licencing is available
on our tutorials page here
WINDOW MANAGERS
Microsoft Windows comes
with one standard window manager and for most people that's all they
ever see. The window manager is the graphical user interface - an
operating system shell that lets you navigate and work using a mouse
instead of having to type arcane commands into a text-based shell.
Windows has a text-based shell too. This
is the Dos shell, where you can still use all the old Dos commands.
In the Linux world, things are a little more complicated. Linux
has a text-based shell, but the big distributions also come with
XWindows - a windowing system common across many Unix operating
systems.
XWindows on its own is pretty rudimentary and there are two popular
desktop managers that sit on top of XWindows in Linux. The K Desktop
Environment (KDE) has been around longest, while the Gnome (pronounced
G-nome) desktop is relatively recent and has the backing of many
major Unix players. In practice, there is little to choose between
them and the major Linux installations allow you to install either
or both. If you install both, you can easily switch between them
at a later date.
WINDOWS OPERATING SYSTEMS
Windows does not come with
bundled applications and most computer manufacturers bundle them separately.
Where Windows really comes into its own is with games and business
application software. Not surprisingly, Microsoft has refused to port
its Office suite to other PC operating systems like Linux and without
Office many other desktop application vendors sees Linux lacking credibility
on the desktop although this is changing (see below).
There
are still relatively few big name games available for Linux and
even those games developers who are keen to port their software
often find publishers unwilling to cater for what is still seen
as a small market. There was a time when there was only one Windows
operating system. Now the platform has forked into many different
versions for different uses.
WINDOWS XP (HOME & PROFESSIONAL)
Windows XP, Microsoft's flagship system, unites
two historically separate threads of Windows development: the 'client'
side systems - running from Windows 3.1 through 95 and 98 to ME -
and the 'server' side of Windows represented by Windows NT and then
2000.
Windows XP also benefits from - or suffers, depending on
your feelings about simple primary colours - a redesigned user interface.
Those who don't like the new look can always choose to switch to
the 'classic' Windows interface. But however you look at it, the
operating system has been praised for its ease of use and it represents
the most stable system Microsoft has produced - stability long overdue,
many believe.
Windows XP also features improved support for multimedia - with
a beefed up Windows Media player and the integration of Internet
Explorer 6, there is also Windows Movie Maker, a simple digital
editing application. It also comes with integrated Roxio CD-burning
software, and Microsoft's Windows Messenger, for instant messaging.
While the Home edition is aimed at consumers and the Professional
edition at business users, this does not mean that small businesses
should ignore the fully-featured - and cheaper - Home edition.
How do the two editions compare? Essentially, Windows XP Professional
contains everything found in the Home Edition but adds certain system
management features. For example, security issues are simplified
in the Home edition - anyone logging on to a Home machine has full
control over it. The Professional edition supports up to two processors
in the machine, while Home only supports one. The professional Edition
supports Remote Desktop - a single session version of Terminal Services.
The Home edition has no backup utility. Professional supports EFS
(Encryption File System) so that you can encrypt individual files
or folders for local security. Other networking features not found
in Home include SNMP, simple TCP/IP services and client services
for NetWare, Network Monitor and the Multiple Roaming Feature.
WINDOWS 2000 WORKSTATION
Windows 95 is no longer sold. Windows 98 was a
great improvement in terms of speed and stability and it also added
built-in support for USB, which was always a difficult and unreliable
upgrade under Windows 95. Now Windows 98 is taking a back seat too,
to Windows 2000 Workstation in the workplace and Windows ME for the
home user.
Windows 2000 offers better security and more stability than you'll
find in either Windows 98 or Windows ME, but lacks some of the multimedia
enhancements that made it into Windows ME, such as Windows Media
Player. Support for video and sound cards and joysticks is more
restricted too in Windows 2000, making it unsuitable for game play.
WINDOWS ME
Windows ME has features
aimed specifically at the home user, such as home networking and tutorials,
wizards and a redesigned help centre. This operating system is based
on the Windows 95/98 core but includes new protection for system files,
faster start-up and better hibernate/resume features. It should also
work with all Windows 98 drivers and applications, so if you're planning
to upgrade from Windows 98 you should not have to replace any other
software.
A new home networking wizard
that is not included in the Windows 2000 platform was deigned to
make setting up networks at home a breeze. The most important improvement
perhaps is the addition of new drivers and compression technologies
to make working with digital images easier. Windows Movie Maker
lets you produce movies, while the new Media Player doubles up as
an impressive jukebox. It also has built-in safeguards to minimise
the risk of user errors that could damage the system.
WINDOWS 2000 SERVER
Microsoft now produces three server operating systems
in addition to the old Windows NT 4, which is still available. Windows
2000 Server is a small office server operating system, while Windows
2000 Advanced Server is for more complicated networks. Windows 2000
Datacenter Server is for huge installations where the hardware can
have anything up to 32 processors. Windows 2000 Server is simplified
for less-experienced technicians and boasts ActiveDirectory, which
lets you administer a server from one location, using a simple series
of clicks.
UNIX
Unix was developed at the University of Berkley
in California during the 1970s and the original code has been adapted
over the years into many different flavours by many different companies.
Unix was intended to be a multi-user operating system, unlike Dos
and Windows, which were originally developed as single user operating
systems.
Unix operating systems generally have reputations as being very
robust, rarely requiring a reboot, and their multi-user nature means
that you can set up a Unix operating system so that dozens and even
hundreds of users can log into a machine. With Windows, you would
have to buy one of the server versions to enable users to log on.
LINUX
Linux comes with hundreds and even thousands of
utilities and applications. Some distributions include office suites,
such as ApplixWare or Sun's StarOffice, both of which provide a similar
level of functionality to Microsoft Office (and can read and write
Microsoft Office file formats). Most come with file and Web server
applications such as, respectively, Samba and Apache. This means that
you have all the software you need, right off the cuff, to set up
your own file server or Web server.
LINUX DISTRIBUTIONS
As noted above, the GNU
public licence allows anybody to take a copy of Linux, package it
how they like and redistribute it, so long as it is sold on with the
same GNU public licence. A number of companies have been built up
around this idea, most notably Red Hat, Caldera, TurboLinux and SuSE.
These firms, which are known as Linux
distributors, each sell a version of Linux that is often tailored
by their own software engineers together with hundreds and sometimes
thousands of Linux utilities and applications. Many of these are
also governed by the GNU public licence but some may work under
different licences or may be demos of commercial (that is, you have
to pay for it) software.
We hope this buying advice article gave you
some tips on what to look out for when choosing an item to buy that
suits your needs.
We welcome feedback and additions to our tutorials / how-to's and
tips feel free to contact us with
your ideas and updates.
we could have
set up our own domain name registration service but our prices would
have been high and we don't want to overcharge customers so we recommend
you use